High Diamonds (85+ OVR)

Every card rated 85 Overall or better in MLB The Show 26, priced live and ranked by market value.

Showing 50 of 688 priced cards, most expensive first. Browse the full market →

Prices last fetched Thu, 15 Oct 2026 14:26:55 GMT. Figures are cached for up to five minutes.

Card	POS	OVR	OpScoreⓘ	Buy Nowⓘ	Sell Orderⓘ	Vol/hrⓘ	Profitⓘ	ROIⓘ	Value Gapⓘ	Signalⓘ	Quirks
Jacob Misiorowski 2026 All-Star	SP	Red Diamond99	98.6 +12 #349 · #26 SP	849,500	717,888	—	+46,660	6.5%	Pro	Pro	+1
Shohei Ohtani2-Way Live	SP	Red Diamond95	88.6 +11 #835 · #130 SP	520,000	441,500	—	+26,498	6.0%	Pro	Pro	+6
Babe Ruth Contributor	LF	Diamond92	83.1 +11 #1105 · #92 LF	500,000	355,001	—	+94,997	26.8%	Pro	Pro	+5
Mike Trout Awards	CF	Red Diamond99	108.0 +14 #70 · #7 CF	484,990	420,000	—	+16,489	3.9%	Pro	Pro	+5
Roch Cholowsky 2026 Draft	SS	Red Diamond99	98.1 +13 #370 · #49 SS	419,320	332,000	—	+45,386	13.7%	Pro	Pro	+4
Ozzie Smith Awards	SS	Red Diamond99	114.4 +15 #10 · #2 SS	409,000	350,000	—	+18,098	5.2%	Pro	Pro	+2
Chone Figgins Moonshot	3B	Red Diamond99	113.8 +15 #12 · #1 3B	400,000	350,000	—	+9,998	2.9%	Pro	Pro	+4
Aaron Judge Live	RF	Diamond93	82.8 +11 #1118 · #104 RF	386,996	327,000	—	+21,294	6.5%	Pro	Pro	+7
Jorge Posada Subway	C	Red Diamond99	117.3 +15 #3 · #2 C	381,990	323,058	—	+20,731	6.4%	Pro	Pro	+4
John Donaldson2-Way The Negro Leagues	SP	Red Diamond99	103.1 +10 #193 · #9 SP	355,000	311,111	—	+8,387	2.7%	Pro	Pro	+1
Lance Berkman Postseason	RF	Red Diamond97	94.8 +12 #524 · #46 RF	340,000	300,000	—	+5,998	2.0%	Pro	Pro	+5
Leo De Vries Pipeline	SS	Red Diamond99	106.6 +14 #99 · #15 SS	339,996	289,103	—	+16,891	5.8%	Pro	Pro	+4
Munetaka Murakami World Baseball Classic	1B	Diamond90	85.2 +11 #1022 · #105 1B	315,554	230,001	—	+53,995	23.5%	Pro	Pro	+3
Shohei Ohtani2-Way 2026 All-Star	SP	Red Diamond99	99.2 +13 #315 · #23 SP	315,000	250,088	—	+33,410	13.4%	Pro	Pro	+5
Juan Soto All-Star	RF	Red Diamond95	88.6 +12 #835 · #80 RF	305,000	260,000	—	+14,498	5.6%	Pro	Pro	+6
Cal Raleigh Milestone	C	Red Diamond99	106.2 +14 #106 · #21 C	295,500	250,368	—	+15,580	6.2%	Pro	Pro	+4
Chili Davis Milestone	CF	Red Diamond99	104.5 +14 #145 · #16 CF	253,997	208,050	—	+20,545	9.9%	Pro	Pro	+4
Jonathan Broxton Prime	CP	Red Diamond99	110.2 +14 #34 · #1 CP	237,000	187,008	—	+26,290	14.1%	Pro	Pro	+1
Billy Wagner Finest	CP	Red Diamond99	108.4 +14 #61 · #2 CP	234,975	206,000	—	+5,475	2.7%	Pro	Pro	+1
Cliff Lee Awards	SP	Red Diamond99	90.2 +6 #743 · #102 SP	212,499	171,268	—	+19,979	11.7%	Pro	Pro
Willie McGee Awards	CF	Red Diamond99	109.5 +14 #44 · #5 CF	200,898	169,031	—	+11,775	7.0%	Pro	Pro	+3
Logan Webb World Baseball Classic	SP	Diamond89	85.0 +9 #1033 · #175 SP	193,999	162,501	—	+12,096	7.4%	Pro	Pro	+1
Geraldo Perdomo Awards	SS	Red Diamond99	99.0 +13 #325 · #43 SS	184,995	147,550	—	+18,943	12.8%	Pro	Pro	+6
Larry Walker Finest	RF	Red Diamond99	109.5 +14 #44 · #2 RF	169,992	144,204	—	+8,786	6.1%	Pro	Pro	+5
Ronald Acuña Jr. World Baseball Classic	RF	Diamond90	83.6 +11 #1081 · #103 RF	156,500	130,131	—	+10,717	8.2%	Pro	Pro	+4
Al Leiter Signature	SP	Red Diamond97	90.0 +9 #761 · #110 SP	153,000	128,163	—	+9,535	7.4%	Pro	Pro	+1
Adrian Beltre Awards	3B	Red Diamond99	105.1 +14 #130 · #13 3B	145,479	117,105	—	+13,824	11.8%	Pro	Pro	+5
Spencer Strider Rookie	SP	Diamond91	84.4 +8 #1056 · #181 SP	144,993	105,500	—	+24,991	23.7%	Pro	Pro
Mike Trout 2026 All-Star	CF	Red Diamond99	98.7 +13 #342 · #44 CF	143,649	109,517	—	+19,765	18.0%	Pro	Pro	+4
Bryce Harper Milestone	1B	Red Diamond98	101.8 +13 #224 · #34 1B	141,000	126,000	—	+898	0.7%	Pro	Pro	+5
Randy Johnson 2nd Half Heroes	SP	Diamond92	87.8 +7 #878 · #136 SP	140,000	101,201	—	+24,797	24.5%	Pro	Pro	+1
David Wright Awards	3B	Red Diamond99	106.2 +14 #106 · #7 3B	137,199	110,112	—	+13,365	12.1%	Pro	Pro	+3
Pedro Martinez Milestone	SP	Red Diamond99	105.5 +14 #122 · #3 SP	134,994	112,508	—	+8,984	8.0%	Pro	Pro	+3
Manny Ramirez Milestone	LF	Red Diamond99	100.4 +13 #272 · #12 LF	127,000	106,000	—	+8,298	7.8%	Pro	Pro	+7
Stan Musial Milestone	LF	Red Diamond99	104.4 +13 #151 · #4 LF	124,999	102,239	—	+10,258	10.0%	Pro	Pro	+7
Terry Pendleton Awards	3B	Red Diamond99	108.8 +13 #54 · #2 3B	118,880	95,028	—	+11,962	12.6%	Pro	Pro	+1
Paul Skenes 2026 All-Star	SP	Red Diamond98	99.5 +9 #309 · #22 SP	114,950	85,504	—	+17,949	21.0%	Pro	Pro	+1
Anibal Sanchez Milestone	SP	Red Diamond99	99.8 +7 #296 · #18 SP	114,894	91,001	—	+12,401	13.6%	Pro	Pro	+1
Jered Weaver Milestone	SP	Red Diamond99	95.9 +6 #467 · #48 SP	109,848	93,116	—	+5,745	6.2%	Pro	Pro
Joe Morgan Hall of Fame	2B	Red Diamond99	111.4 +14 #20 · #2 2B	108,000	97,008	—	+190	0.2%	Pro	Pro	+5
Roger Clemens All-Star	SP	Red Diamond97	95.3 +9 #494 · #54 SP	107,498	79,303	—	+17,443	22.0%	Pro	Pro	+1
Yordan Alvarez Postseason	LF	Diamond94	85.2 +11 #1022 · #83 LF	105,800	93,000	—	+2,218	2.4%	Pro	Pro	+3
Ray Durham Signature	2B	Red Diamond99	106.4 +14 #101 · #13 2B	102,999	78,009	—	+14,688	18.8%	Pro	Pro	+5
Rafael Devers Milestone	3B	Red Diamond97	93.6 +9 #565 · #53 3B	101,499	82,223	—	+9,124	11.1%	Pro	Pro	+3
Ozzie Albies 2026 All-Star	2B	Red Diamond98	99.8 +13 #296 · #31 2B	100,999	81,500	—	+9,397	11.5%	Pro	Pro	+4
Pete Crow-Armstrong Milestone	CF	Red Diamond96	99.3 +13 #313 · #39 CF	100,750	76,000	—	+14,673	19.3%	Pro	Pro	+3
Johan Santana Milestone	SP	Red Diamond99	93.8 +7 #552 · #64 SP	100,069	81,501	—	+8,559	10.5%	Pro	Pro	+1
Vladimir Guerrero Milestone	RF	Red Diamond99	106.9 +14 #87 · #4 RF	100,000	90,000	—	—	—	Pro	Pro	+5
Bernie Williams 2nd Half Heroes	CF	Diamond92	84.4 +11 #1056 · #109 CF	99,989	87,070	—	+2,918	3.4%	Pro	Pro	+3
Victor Martinez Postseason	C	Diamond92	101.7 +13 #226 · #36 C	98,900	91,000	—	—	—	Pro	Pro	+5

About high diamonds (85+ ovr)

Eighty-five Overall is the line where a card stops being a stopgap and starts being an answer. This cut is the whole pool above it, which makes it the practical shopping list for a competitive lineup rather than a highlight reel of the ten cards nobody can afford.

What to watch here: Overall is one number that never changes with difficulty. Two 87s can be a full tier apart in practice, which is what OpScore on each row is for.

Every row carries the live buy-now price, the best sell order, the spread between them, and each card’s OpScore — our re-weighting of the attributes that actually decide at-bats, rather than the single headline number the in-game Overall reports. Click any card for its full price history, quirks and OpScore breakdown.

Prices come from the in-game marketplace and are re-polled continuously. Cards with no buy-now listing are excluded from this page rather than shown at zero stubs — nobody selling is not the same thing as free.

Other market cuts: Most Expensive Cards · Live Series Cards · Live Series Diamonds · Live Series Golds · Live Series Silvers · Live Series Bronzes · Live Series Commons · Diamonds Under 25,000 Stubs · Golds Under 5,000 Stubs · Best Cards Under 25,000 Stubs

Reading the market

Common questions

How many cards are in the High Diamonds (85+ OVR) list?

688 cards currently match this cut and carry a live buy-now price. This page shows the top 50 by price; the full set is filterable on the market page.

Why is a card missing from this list?

Two reasons. Either it does not match the cut, or it has no buy-now listing at all — cards nobody is selling are left out instead of being priced at zero. A card can also drop off within minutes of its last listing selling.

Are these prices live?

They come from the in-game marketplace, which we re-poll continuously. Signed out, this page serves them from a cache that can be up to five minutes old. Either way the “prices last fetched” stamp above the table is the real fetch time, not the time you loaded the page, so you can judge the age yourself rather than take our word for it.